2009年4月7日 星期二

Antoni Wit版Karol Szymanowski管弦樂作品全集

指揮家Simon Rattle談Karol Szymanowski:

"I cannot talk objectively about Szymanowski, for you cannot expect objectivity or reasonability from someone in love. And reasonability is out of place when this music is concerned, anyway. My first meeting with Szymanowski took place some fifteen years ago. I was having lunch with my friend Paul Crossley, the English pianist. Paul was a man whose advice I used unscrupulously. We would often meet, and he would put a score in front of me and say, 'You should have a look'. But that night he said, 'I've got something special for you', then sat at the piano and played a bit of some piece. I had no idea what it was, but it got me very excited after just a few strokes and I knew it was love from first sight. It was the last part of the 'Stabat Mater' that Paul had played.

The 'Stabat Mater' was in the programme of one of my first concerts with the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra. I must admit with shame that the choir sang in Latin. We knew, though, that a Polish language version would need to be prepared. And we struggled with that difficult language. Only Finnish and Hungarian are said to be more difficult, and there is not too much similarity between the Birmingham dialect and the Polish language. Only ten letters are pronounced the same in English and in Polish. So it was a character building experience for us on all counts. It took a year to work with the choir, but apparently sopranos can now be understood. I suppose that if Poles tried to sing in Welsh, they would understand our problems. We reached a point where language started to impact the sound of music, its rhythm. For instance, the holding out of the vowels and the proper start of the consonants has lent this music a specific puls. The choir was no longer a group of English singers feeling aloof about a strange, obscure composition. They began to penetrate the music. It was an extraordinary trip. Szymanowski's music bought the ensemble, the choir and the orchestra. We played the 'Stabat Mater' many times, then moved on to 'Symphony No. 3'...

I think we got our timing right with this music. The world was not ready to take it until now. Szymanowski's religious works, such as the 'Stabat Mater' or the 'Litany to the Virgin Mary', respond to the ever more pronounced need for spirituality. Moreover, this music is so splendidly colourful and extremely emotional. The English were at first unable to accept its highly intense and direct emotionality, they had to grow up to it. Now we are ready for it. It has always amazed me why the violinists of the world do not play at least one of Szymanowski's concertos and why the pianists do not play his 'Symphony concertante'. These compositions could have enriched the global repertoire a long time ago. Nowadays it is very important not to limit yourself to twenty or thirty compositions recorded by Toscanini. The public is open to new repertoire. Witness the success of Gorecki. Gorecki has been successful not only with the traditional philharmonic audience. He has a new audience in England, one that did not listen to serious music before. I believe it could be the same with Szymanowski.

I owe the discovery of Szymanowski's 'Symphony No. 3' to Witold Lutoslawski. He said that he had lived in something like a trance for several weeks after he had heard it. It was this music which prompted Lutoslawski to decide he wanted to be a composer. 'Symphony No. 3' is a wonderful, mystical work revealing fascination with the Orient. Its climate meets the needs of contemporary listeners. Yet I believe that it is Szymanowski's later works, when he addresses the Polish heritage, reaches down to the Slavonic roots, makes a sort of reference to Musorgski, is even more valuable for our culture at present. At the end of the twentieth century the rest of the world should discover what you have always known: that Szymanowski is one of the greatest composers of this century". ("Studio" 1994 No. 10)





Naxos美國錄音版圖再下一城:休斯頓交響樂團


2009年5月,Naxos公司將推出休斯頓交響樂團(Houston Symphony Orchestra)在該公司的首部錄音,由該團音樂總監Hans Graf指揮,早在2007年秋季完成的錄音,由資資深製作人Michael Fine操刀,曲目則是Alexander Zemlinsky的抒情交響曲(Lyric Symphony)與Anton Berg 的三首管弦樂曲(3 Pieces from the Lyric Suite)。

Marin Alsop馬勒交響曲錄音何時推出?


本月3至5日,美國女指揮家Marin Alsop剛完成與巴爾的摩交響樂團(Baltimore Symphony Orchestra)的馬勒第九號交響曲音樂會,美國主流媒體褒貶不一。像是華盛頓郵報(Washington Post)的樂評Anne Midgette似乎就不太欣賞這場音樂會,覺得熱情有所不足,不過當地報紙巴爾的摩太陽報樂評Tim Smith倒是蠻捧場的,給予相當正面的評價。
在此同時,Marin Alsop也四處征戰,預計6月份將指揮洛杉磯愛樂(Los Angeles Philharmonic )演奏馬勒第五號交響曲,明年1月則指揮休斯頓交響樂團(Houston Symphony O)演出馬勒第一號交響曲。
本網誌去年10月即預告過Marin Alsop與巴爾的摩交響樂團的馬勒第一號交響曲錄音早已完成,可惜,Naxos公司遲遲未推出,另外,德弗札克第七、八號交響曲,是與第九號新世界交響曲一起完成的,但不知何故也一直延宕...

2009年4月6日 星期一

皇家利物浦愛樂會是另一個伯明罕市立交響樂團?


英國Presto Classical網站剛剛寄來四月六日的電子報,推薦由Vasily Petrenko指揮皇家利物浦愛樂( Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra )的蕭斯塔高維奇第十一號交響曲。其中,第一段這麼說的:

There is something of a revolution going on at the Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra (RLPO) under their young principal conductor Vasily Petrenko. I

而最後一段則是這麼寫的:

In the 1980s the CBSO carried out a remarkable transformation from ‘good’ to ‘world class’ under the leadership of a certain Simon Rattle. It seems that Vasily Petrenko has a similar transformation in mind for his orchestra. And on this evidence you wouldn’t want to bet against him.


這張CD之前曾經高掛英國Gramophone雜誌Specialist Classical Chart暢銷排行榜第三名,上週則掉到第十名。不過,同榜的第六名是James Judd指揮博恩茅斯交響樂團(Bournemouth SO)的Bax交響作品,第七名則是Graham Ross 指揮Dmitri Ensemble演奏英國現代作曲家James MacMillan的宗教曲目Seven Last Words from the Cross。排名前十名有三張Naxos錄音,係所有唱片公司中最大贏家!

2009年4月5日 星期日

便宜有好貨:Naxos打敗拉圖與柏林愛樂


Newsweek雜誌網路版二月初專訪歐巴馬時代的「新文化沙皇」(New Culture Czar)作曲家John Adams,談新政府應該如何提倡精緻藝術,其中有一段針對廉價唱片廠牌Naxos的評語:

Newsweek:The budget-label Naxos label seems to be doing well.

John Adams:Yeah, they do [all right], but their product is so mediocre.They must have made … seven or eight CDs of my work. They're poorly produced. In some cases, the performances are OK, and in some cases the performances are disgraceful. It's like going to Costco and buying toilet paper with no brand on it.

Newsweek:Which recordings would you steer people away from?

John Adams:Well, I wouldn't say it for the record.

購買量販店或連鎖商店的自有品牌商品並沒有甚麼不對!省掉中間大筆行銷費用,但一樣是由市場上領導品牌的製造商代工製造;舉例來說,屈臣氏的衛生紙一樣是由大廠永×餘代工,在不景氣的現在,實在沒有理由只為了迷信品牌而浪費錢吧。購買自用品牌商品反而是一種非常划算的聰明消費行為呢!

更何況,若非Naxos公司「平凡的二流錄音」,大量20世紀現代作曲家罕見曲目根本沒有機會灌錄成唱片,讓更多愛樂者以最低的代價欣賞到這些連音樂廳都不一定有機會演出的作品,John Adams此番不識時務的評論,不禁讓人聯想到「何不食肉靡」囈語....

舉例來說,樂評家Andrew Clements 於英國衛報評論近期兩張拉威爾《小孩與魔法》(L'enfant et les Sortileges),便是最好的一個例子。一張是EMI出版,由Simon Rattle指揮柏林愛樂,另一張則是Naxos出版,由Alastair Willis(從沒聽過?!)指揮 Nashville Symphony(連B咖樂團,恐怕都算不上吧!?),表面上看起來似乎無法相提並論,但樂評是這麼說的:
No composer has evoked the world of childhood more magically than Ravel, and the two works in which he did so most potently - the ballet Ma Mère l'Oye and the one-act opera L'Enfant et les Sortilèges, with its deft, tender text by Colette - make an obvious pairing. Both pieces bring the best out of Simon Rattle, too, and throughout this disc, recorded in Berlin last autumn, his graceful grading of the orchestral textures and perfectly paced unfolding of its melodies is a pleasure in itself.

But despite Rattle's beautifully realised evocations, and the Berlin Philharmoniker's exquisitely coloured scene painting, the performance of L'Enfant never quite takes off. Magdalena Kozena's Child is more grande dame than naughty youngster, while the rest of the cast, including Annick Massis, Nathalie Stutzmann, José Van Dam and François Le Roux, never really get into their collections of cameos either. It's all a bit too genteel, too refined in the wrong sense of the word. And though the playing of the Nashville Symphony on the Naxos disc can't begin to compete with the Berlin sound, there's something about the spirit of that performance under Alastair Willis, with Julie Boulianne as the Child, that seems closer to what Ravel might have had in mind. The performance of Ma Mère l'Oye may be worth the price of the EMI disc alone, but the delicate flavour of the opera comes across far more effectively in the Naxos account.

便宜有好貨:BIS版葛立格霍爾堡組曲獲企鵝指南四星戴花

上文提及2006-2007年版企鵝指南,有五個錄音被授予“四星帶花”的最高評等,其中有2張CD錄音、2張SACD、還有1張DVD,其中一張SACD錄音已被打入低價位,改成CD形式發行,台灣很容易買得到的,那就是BIS公司發行的葛立格管弦樂曲全集(8CDs,BIS-CD-1740~42),由Ole Kristian Ruud指揮挪威Bergen Philharmonic Orchestra。

獲得四星戴花殊榮的是其中第7張CD霍爾堡組曲及其它弦樂作品。

便宜有好貨:Alsop版布蘭詩歌摘下企鵝四星&必備盤


在原本的三顆星與三星戴花之外,2006年版英國企鵝指南(Penguin Guide)開始推出四顆星評等機制,甚至將唯一的四星戴花桂冠頒給了廉價廠牌Naxos的TALLIS: Spem in alium / Missa Salve intemerata(8.557770,Jeremy Summerly指揮Oxford Camerata)。



根據大陸網友的統計,2006-2007年版企鵝指南中,又有五個錄音被授予“四星帶花”的評級,其中四片CD中又有一張是屬於Naxos公司的錄音~瑞典作曲家林德(Bo LINDE)的小提琴協奏曲與大提琴協奏曲(8.557855,Sundkvist指揮瑞典Gavle交響樂團,小提琴:Karen Gomyo,大提琴:Maria Kliegel)。





日昨翻閱2009年版Naxos新版目錄,美國女指揮家Marin Alsop指揮的布蘭詩歌(8.570033),獲得了四顆星評價,雖然沒有戴花,但是特別加上了鑰匙(Key Recording,「必備盤」)的標誌,儘管還是無法與Sony版Ormandy的四顆星戴花相提並論,但Alosp可望以此一錄音豐碑名留古典音樂錄音史,如果還有人質疑Naxos的錄音水準或女性指揮家的實力,just try this...